Concerns of Appropriating Pueblo Culture and Identity in Media
Appropriating Pueblo culture in painting, photography, video, and film comes with serious ethical, historical, and social concerns. Pueblo communities have long been represented by outsiders, often in ways that are romanticized, inaccurate, or exploitative. Understanding these concerns is essential for any artist working in the Southwest, especially for those of us who have cultural ties to the region and want to engage with it in a way that is respectful, truthful, and ethical.
1. Sacred and Private Traditions
Many Pueblo ceremonies, dances, and rituals are not meant for public display—whether in paintings, photographs, or film. These traditions hold deep spiritual significance, and many have already been misused or commodified by non-Pueblo artists and media makers.
Common Issues:
- Capturing ceremonies or religious practices without permission.
- Depicting sacred symbols, kachinas, or regalia that are meant to remain within Pueblo communities.
- Using Pueblo traditions as aesthetic decoration without understanding their deeper meanings.
How to Approach This Ethically:
- Ask for permission before using imagery related to Pueblo rituals.
- Avoid depicting sacred ceremonies unless explicitly invited to do so by community members.
- Understand that some symbols are not for public use, and some knowledge is meant to remain within the Pueblos.
2. The “Frozen in Time” Stereotype
Pueblo people are often represented as unchanging, as if they exist only in an old, pre-modern world. This problem is common in Southwestern art, where Pueblo figures are painted or photographed only in traditional clothing, in rural settings, and without any sign of modern life.
Common Issues:
- Only depicting Pueblo people in historic or traditional settings while ignoring contemporary realities.
- Romanticizing Pueblo life as static, timeless, or unchanging rather than acknowledging that Pueblo culture is alive and evolving.
- Reinforcing the idea that Pueblo people only exist in the past, rather than as part of the modern world.
How to Approach This Ethically:
- Represent Pueblo people as they are today, not just in an imagined past.
- Avoid reinforcing stereotypes of “noble savages” or overly simplified depictions.
- Recognize that modern Pueblo communities engage in contemporary life while still maintaining their traditions.
3. Who Profits from Pueblo Imagery?
There is a long history of outsiders profiting from Pueblo culture while the communities themselves receive little to no benefit. This includes everything from tourist photography to Hollywood films that use Pueblo settings and imagery without giving back to the people who live there.
Common Issues:
- Non-Pueblo artists selling paintings or photographs of Pueblo people without their consent.
- Films and documentaries that use Pueblo imagery but do not compensate or credit the communities involved.
- Using Pueblo culture as a commercial aesthetic without contributing to or acknowledging its people.
How to Approach This Ethically:
- Share benefits with the community—whether through direct compensation, collaboration, or reinvestment in Pueblo projects.
- Get informed consent when using Pueblo imagery, especially in commercial art and media.
- Acknowledge the source of cultural inspiration rather than taking without credit.
4. The Issue of Outsider Narratives
Most media about Pueblo people has been created by outsiders, leading to stories that are often inaccurate, romanticized, or misleading. Pueblo communities have their own ways of telling their histories, but mainstream media often replaces those voices with non-Native perspectives.
Common Issues:
- Non-Pueblo artists and filmmakers telling Pueblo stories without input from the community.
- Documentaries and films that focus on Pueblo struggles without also showing their strength, resilience, and joy.
- Using Pueblo imagery as a backdrop without including real Pueblo voices.
How to Approach This Ethically:
- Collaborate with Pueblo voices rather than speaking for them.
- Recognize Pueblo agency—tell stories with, not about, Pueblo people.
- Avoid narratives that only focus on suffering or the past—include the full complexity of Pueblo life.
5. Misuse of Pueblo Language and Symbols
Language and symbolism are deeply important in Pueblo cultures, yet they are often misused in art and media. Many Pueblo languages are endangered, and taking words or phrases out of context can be harmful. Similarly, Pueblo symbols, including designs on pottery and textiles, have specific meanings that are often ignored or misrepresented.
Common Issues:
- Using Pueblo words or phrases without understanding their meaning.
- Copying traditional Pueblo designs without permission or context.
- Incorporating religious or spiritual symbols into commercial art or fashion.
How to Approach This Ethically:
- Learn from Pueblo people directly if you want to use language or symbols.
- Do not copy sacred or traditional designs without understanding their meaning and significance.
- If using Pueblo imagery, make sure it is done with respect and acknowledgment of its origins.
Final Thoughts: Being a Responsible Artist
As someone with Hispanic heritage growing up in communities tied closely to pueblo lands, my relationship with Pueblo culture is complex. I want to honor the deep connections between Hispano and Pueblo communities while also recognizing the boundaries of what is mine to share.
- Respect is at the core of ethical representation. Asking, listening, and engaging with Pueblo communities directly is essential.
- Truth over aesthetics—I strive to create work that is both beautiful and real, not just what sells or fits a marketable Southwest fantasy.
- Giving back—if I benefit from Pueblo culture in my work, I want to find ways to contribute to those communities.
Art and media are powerful tools for storytelling, but they also come with responsibility. By being aware of these concerns, I aim to create work that is thoughtful, ethical, and rooted in real relationships with the cultures that inspire it.
Comments are closed.